Article Evaluation Form

Points for reviewers to consider:

 

  • Is the study an original contribution in its field?
  • Does the manuscript contain errors in inference, interpretation, or statistical analysis?
  • Is the presentation clear, concise and well-organised?
  • Is the abstract informative, giving the essence of the research in clear terms?
  • Please keep your comments professional and objective.

 
* Required

    Recommendation*
    Accept the manuscript in its present formAccept after minor revisions; do not send me the revision for a second reviewRequires major revision; send me the revised version for a second evaluationReject

    Summary Rating*

    Originality
    ExcellentGoodFairPoor
    Technical quality
    ExcellentGoodFairPoor
    Clarity of presentation
    ExcellentGoodFairPoor
    Practical significance
    ExcellentGoodFairPoor

    Scroll to Top